Due to multiple replays in the FA Cup, in the 1991/92 season the competition introduced one replay followed by a penalty shootout. The first to go to a penalty decider were Rotherham United versus Scunthorpe United, with the Millers claiming victory.
| Nickname of club | The Millers |
|---|---|
| League | League One |
| Date established | 1925 |
| Location | Rotherham |
| Stadium | AESSEAL New York Stadium |
| Address | New York Way, Rotherham, South Yorkshire, S60 1FJ |
| Year stadium built | 2012 |
| Stadium capacity | 12,021 |
| Club manager | Steve Evans |
| Mascot | Miller Bear |
| Young supporters club | Junior Millers |
| Club website | http://www.themillers.co.uk |
| Club community organisation information | http://www.themillers.co.uk/club/community |